by Late in March 2021, then-German Chancellor Angela Merkel announced a reverse. Several weeks before that time, Merkel’s federal government had reached an agreement with the various states to begin opening the country back up, easing more modest restrictions to move daily life closer to normal. But with case counts sharply rising once more, the whole thing was going to get shutdown instead. The government declared a holiday starting April 1 (no fooling) last year, lasting three days while totally banning any large public gatherings (except those by and for government officials, obviously) for nearly a week. Other restrictions were either applied or kept in place. You know the drill. As a consequence of these draconian measures, retail sales in Germany crashed. Of
Topics:
Jeffrey P. Snider considers the following as important: 5.) Alhambra Investments, Christine Lagarde, CPI, currencies, economy, Featured, Federal Reserve/Monetary Policy, Germany, HICP, inflation, Markets, newsletter, Recession, Retail sales
This could be interesting, too:
Marc Chandler writes Sterling and Gilts Pressed Lower by Firmer CPI
Ryan McMaken writes A Free-Market Guide to Trump’s Immigration Crackdown
Wanjiru Njoya writes Post-Election Prospects for Ending DEI
Swiss Customs writes Octobre 2024 : la chimie-pharma détermine le record à l’export
| Late in March 2021, then-German Chancellor Angela Merkel announced a reverse. Several weeks before that time, Merkel’s federal government had reached an agreement with the various states to begin opening the country back up, easing more modest restrictions to move daily life closer to normal. But with case counts sharply rising once more, the whole thing was going to get shutdown instead.
The government declared a holiday starting April 1 (no fooling) last year, lasting three days while totally banning any large public gatherings (except those by and for government officials, obviously) for nearly a week. Other restrictions were either applied or kept in place. You know the drill. As a consequence of these draconian measures, retail sales in Germany crashed. Of course they did give how pretty much every German was stuck at home with little commerce available outside of it for a sizable chunk of that month. |
 . |
| According to deStatis, the government’s bean counting agency, accounting for price changes (which weren’t changing all that quickly early last year) retail trade collapsed by 6.6% in April 2021 when compared to the month before. Shut the whole country down, get nearly minus seven m/m.
Dismissed as the inevitable non-economic consequences of government COVID-fighting, the same process was repeated a couple more times over the year since then with similar though less extreme retail sales results. The government acts, commerce falls substantially, everyone presumes the economy goes right back to good or awesome when the acts are lifted. But in April 2022, there was no COVID panic. Going by German retail trade numbers, however, you’d be forgiven for thinking there had been. According to the latest estimates from deStatis, retail sales crashed by 5.4% in April 2022 when compared to March; nearly identical m/m results from the prior April. Only this time, no case count conundrum or overstimulated government in sight. No one can blame the pandemic for this one. |
 . |
This is all economics (small “e”).
They will and already have fingered Russia, of course, but even when doing so mainstream commentary is rightly fixed on the bigger issue – the emerging downside to last year’s supply shock (sales in real terms have been falling since last June, coincident to Euro$ #5). Paying more and getting less (shown above) has a particularly insidious way of eroding economic fundamentals, especially when what you’re paying more for is the basics like gasoline and energy.
No one is, or will be, doing that quite like the Germans. Even nominal retail sales in April went down sharply, a warning that demand destruction isn’t just a real possibility, it can turn up (meaning down) just that quickly and severely when the conditions are right.
This is no geographic outlier, either. What’s going on over there is happening everywhere to a similar enough degree. And, it has to be stated, this has nothing to do with rate hikes (which haven’t even begun in Europe, and this is one key reason why).
Recessions aren’t just oversized downturns or slowdowns, they are a step beyond those, made so by an unusually bad set of circumstances producing unusually awful results. Speaking of and for not just Germany but globally, you have to consider these retail sales estimates as highly unusual in that sense.
What a difference a year makes, or, in the growing case of globally synchronized, doesn’t for retailers. Out of the frying pan of non-economic government interference and into the fire of not inflation but something looking worse.
You Might Also Like
President Phillips Emerges To Reassure On Growing Slowdown
2022-06-02
Just the other day, President Biden took to the pages of the Wall Street Journal to reassure Americans the government is doing something about the greatest economic challenge they face. Biden says this is inflation when that’s neither the actual affliction nor our greatest threat.
Shipping Around Retail ‘Inflation’
2022-05-22
This whole “inflation” scenario isn’t really that difficult to piece together, effect from cause. Sure, Jay Powell’s trying to nuke it by hiking the federal funds rate, but no one really uses fed funds and the problem isn’t the unsecured cost of borrowing bank reserves (not money) that are literally overflowing.
Peak Inflation (not what you think)
2022-05-15
For once, I find myself in agreement with a mainstream article published over at Bloomberg. Notable Fed supporters without fail, this one maybe represents a change in tone. Perhaps the cheerleaders are feeling the heat and are seeking Jay Powell’s exit for him?
Not Good Goods
2022-04-24
The goods economy in the United States is – maybe was – the lone economic bright spot. That in and of itself should’ve provoked more caution, instead there was the red-hot recovery to sell under the cover of supply shock pricing changes. The sheer spending on goods, and how they arrived, each unabashedly artificial from the get-go.
You Know What They Say About The Light At The End Of The Tunnel
2022-04-14
In any year when gasoline prices rise 18%, that’s not going to be good for anyone except maybe oil companies who extract its key ingredient from out of the ground (or don’t, as the case can be). Yet, annual rates of increase that size do happen.
Produzentenfenster Globale Rezessionsuhr
2022-04-13
German optimism was predictably, inevitably sent crashing in March and April 2022. According to that country’s ZEW survey, an uptick in general optimism from November 2021 to February 2022 collided with the reality of Russian armored vehicles trying to snake their way down to Kiev. Whereas sentiment had rebounded from an October low of 22.3, blamed on whichever of the coronas, by February the index had moved upward to 54.3.
Consumer Prices And The Historical Pain(s)
2022-03-12
The 1947-48 experience was truly painful, maybe even terrifying. The US and Europe had just come out of a decade when the worst deflationary consequences were so widespread that the period immediately following quickly erupted into the worst conflagration in human history.
One Shock Case For ‘Irrational Exuberance’ Reaching A Quarter-Century
2021-12-22
Have oil producers shot themselves in the foot, while at the same time stabbing the global economy in the back? It’d be quite a feat if it turns out to be the case, one of those historical oddities that when anyone might honestly look back on it from the future still hung in disbelief. Let’s start by reviewing just the facts.
Tags: Christine Lagarde,CPI,currencies,economy,Featured,Federal Reserve/Monetary Policy,Germany,hicp,inflation,Markets,newsletter,recession,Retail sales