What to Expect from the World Bank and IMF

by
Marc Chandler
My articles My siteAbout meMy booksMy videos
Follow on:TwitterLinkedIN
Seeking Alpha

The spring meetings of the World Bank and IMF will be held virtually this week amid a profound economic crisis spurred by a novel coronavirus. Unlike previous such viruses, this went global in such a destructive way that many countries have responded the same way. Encouraging social distancing, closing non-essential businesses, and enforcing lockdowns. The economic contraction that has begun is beyond what has been seen since the Great Depression. Even before the IMF’s World Economic Outlook is released, Bloomberg Intelligence, the analytic arm of the news service, cautioned that its forecasts would not be sufficiently pessimistic.

The American social historian Studs Terkel called his book on the Great Depression, “Hard Times,” because that is the way most experienced it. It was a Depression for those that had, but so many were struggling to make ends meet and to secure steady employment, that for them, it was just hard times. The same might be said for many of the poorest among us. Not only do many countries not have the resources to combat the virus, but their economies have been crushed. Commodity prices have fallen sharply, (terms of trade shock), trade itself has floundered, foreign private capital has fled, and tourism and worker remittance flows have dried up. Oxfam estimates that 500 mln people could slip into poverty, which it defines as income less than the equivalent of $5.5 a day.

Press reports indicated as more than half of the countries in the world have inquired about IMF assistance and roughly a third of the states have reached out to the World Bank. IMF’s Georgieva noted that three months ago, the IMF expected per capita GDP to rise in 160 of its 189 members. Now it expects it to shrink in 170 members.

The IMF has two emergency lending programs.  The Rapid Credit Facility can offer interest-free loans.  The Rapid Finance Instrument can loan at about 1.5%.  The size of both funds has doubled to $100 bln each.  Reports suggest that countries have requested to draw on these facilities (~$20 bln), and some funds are said to have been distributed.  News accounts suggest the World Bank has received 27 loan requests and as many 40 are in the pipeline.  Together, the IMF and World Bank have over $1.2 trillion of resources to draw upon.

There have been some calls for a new SDR allotment, and some have proposed as much as 500 bln.  This is a huge amount and would more than double the size of the existing supply (~205 bln).  Individual countries are allocated in proportion to their IMF quotas, which means high-income countries and China get the bulk (60%+).  The best way to feed birds is not necessarily to feed the horses more.

Since SDRs cannot be privately held, central banks who want to use them to intervene have to convert them first.  A country wishing to convert their SDRs must find another member willing to buy them.  The IMF can act as an intermediary, but it can, if needed, request a country with ample reserves to purchase the SDRs from a country with low reserves.   It appears that the US and China are among the few countries that have more SDRs than they were allocated.

The IMF and World Bank are encouraging the G20 to declare a moratorium on bilateral government loan repayments.  Bilateral government debt servicing is estimated at around $40 bln.  Officials are focusing on 76 of the world’s poorest countries that are eligible for the World Bank’s International Development Association (IDA).  A 6-9 month freeze is possible, but more ambitious calls want to extend it for next year as well.  There are three levels of assistance that can be offered.  There is debt relief (cancelation of debt), deferment of debt servicing, and re-scheduling of payments.   It cannot be limited to the Paris Club, the informal group of major largely Western creditors, and Japan.  China has emerged as the most significant bilateral lender to  IDA members.

Even this may not be sufficient. Private creditors may need to participate, though it is more challenging to implement.  The Institute of International Finance, an association of (~450) banks and other financial institutions, has called on private creditors to grant to also grant forbearance to the poorest countries as well.  Moreover, low-income countries typically have more debt in domestic hands than by foreign investors.

Separately from the World Economic Outlook, the Global Financial Stability Report will be issued.  The freezing up of the global capital markets has eased, though there has not been a return to the status quo ante.  More extensive central bank action was provided than during the Great Financial Crisis.   Perhaps, the most revealing evidence that the worst is past is that arguments that the “encroachment” of the markets has gone too far and that “moral hazards” have been established, which will encourage poor behavior in the future are beginning to surface. The Federal Reserve’s inclusion of a limited amount of bonds that recently (after the announcement of its two corporate bond-buying facilities) lost their investment-grade status proved too much for some observers.

You Might Also Like

FX Weekly Preview: Sources of Imbalance and the Pushback Against New Divergence

The US dollar’s surge alongside gold has eclipsed the equity market rally as the key development in the capital markets. Even the traditional seemingly safe-haven
yen was no match for the greenback.  The dollar appeared to have been rolling over in Q4 19, as the sentiment surveys in Europe improved, Japanese officials seemingly thought the economy could withstand a sales tax increase, and data suggested the Chinese economy was gaining some traction.  

FX Daily, April 8: Flavor of the Day: Consolidation

Overview: Global equities are struggling after the S&P 500 staged a dramatic reversal yesterday. The early 3.5% gain was completely unwound and closed slightly lower.  With few exceptions (e.g., Japan and the Philippines), most equity markets in the Asia Pacific region and Europe are lower.

Cool Video: OIl, ECB, and Animal Spirits

I had the privilege to join Ben Lichtenstein at TD Ameritrade (from a remote location) this morning to talk about the global markets.  I make four points.  First, the reversal of the S&P 500 yesterday set the tone for Asia and Europe.  Volatility throughout the capital markets remains elevated, even if off the peaks.  

FX Daily, April 9: Three Deals Needed ahead of Holiday Weekend

Overview: Three deals need to be struck. First, the Eurogroup of finance ministers needs to reach an agreement of proposals for joint action to the heads of state. Second, oil producers need to cut output if prices are to stabilize. Third, the US Congress needs to strike a deal to provide more funding. Investor seems hopeful, and risk appetites are have lifted equities.

FX Daily, April 10: Eight Things to Know about Global Capital Markets on Good Friday

Most of the financial centers in Europe and North America are closed today for the Good Friday holiday.  Many markets in Europe will also be closed on Monday. Here is a summary of key developments.

Cool Video: CNBC Asia

As the markets were re-opening in Asia earlier today, I joined Martin Soong and Sir Jegarajah on CNBC Asia.  I had returned from a business trip and visited our summer house on the Jersey shore for what I thought was going to be a weekend more than a month ago.  

FX Daily, April 14: Equities are Firm but New Developments Needed or Risk Appetites may Become Satiated

Overview: Risk appetites have returned today after taking yesterday off. The MSCI Asia Pacific Index advanced every day last week, slipped yesterday, and jumped back today. Most of the national benchmark advanced at least 1.5%, and the Nikkei led the way with a 3% rally to reach its best level since mid-March.

How Risk-Based Healthcare Could Make Us Healthier

It is generally the case that simple concepts in nature produce incredible complexity. This applies to the genome, where simple base pairs have evolved to express complex and multifunctional instructions that would take thousands of lines of code for any human to create. This applies to the economy, where simple ideas such as the price system become infinitely complex at scale.