by Europeans are growing more downbeat again. While ostensibly many are more worried about a new set of restrictions due to (even more overreactions about) COVID, that’s only part of the problem. The bigger factor, economically speaking, is that Europe’s economy has barely moved, or at most not moved near enough, off the bottom. To interrupt now what has already proved to be a seriously impaired rebound should get people thinking more realistically about 2021. Once again, we’re witness to how the need for yet more “stimulus” is being proven – and what that might say about the effectiveness of what’s already been done. That much is universal globally from China to Europe to the US (which we’ll get to in a minute). Beyond this synchronized shortfall there’s reason to
Topics:
Jeffrey P. Snider considers the following as important: 5.) Alhambra Investments, Consumer Confidence, currencies, economy, Europe, Featured, Federal Reserve/Monetary Policy, Fiscal spending, fiscal stimulus, inflation, jobless claims, Markets, newsletter, QE, stimulus
This could be interesting, too:
Nachrichten Ticker - www.finanzen.ch writes Krypto-Ausblick 2025: Stehen Bitcoin, Ethereum & Co. vor einem Boom oder Einbruch?
Connor O'Keeffe writes The Establishment’s “Principles” Are Fake
Per Bylund writes Bitcoiners’ Guide to Austrian Economics
Ron Paul writes What Are We Doing in Syria?
| Europeans are growing more downbeat again. While ostensibly many are more worried about a new set of restrictions due to (even more overreactions about) COVID, that’s only part of the problem. The bigger factor, economically speaking, is that Europe’s economy has barely moved, or at most not moved near enough, off the bottom.
To interrupt now what has already proved to be a seriously impaired rebound should get people thinking more realistically about 2021. Once again, we’re witness to how the need for yet more “stimulus” is being proven – and what that might say about the effectiveness of what’s already been done. That much is universal globally from China to Europe to the US (which we’ll get to in a minute). Beyond this synchronized shortfall there’s reason to key in on Europe’s plight; maybe first, but never an outlier. While it may seem like ancient history, the European economy (Germany, in particular) had started out and remained at the forefront of the quick-developing globally synchronized downturn that spread worldwide right at the outset of 2018 when inflation was, like today, reportedly set to take off. |
European Commision Consumer Confidence Indicator, 2006-2020 - Click to enlarge |
| In other words, watch Europe for what it might mean elsewhere not too far down the road. The Europeans being China’s best marginal customer during the downturn, it certainly helps explain Xi Jinping’s expected emphasis upon “dual circulation” for the foreseeable future for the Chinese economy, which really means unbacked hope for help from China’s rather than Europe’s consumers.
To the latter, the European Commission reported today a sharp drop during October in consumer sentiment in both the European Union as well as the smaller Euro Area bloc. As you can see below, consumers in Europe haven’t exactly been thinking economically happy thoughts much lately anyway. After 6 months of constant “stimulus” and talk about much more of it, and how there can be only more of it, “somehow” European consumers aren’t much into these ideas. Instead, they appear to perceive Europe’s economy right now more like the 2012 or 2008 recessions than a robust rebound of the German business sector’s more globally spaced imagination (even the ZEW faltered in October). |
Germany ZEW Financial Market Survey, 2006-2020 - Click to enlarge |
| In this sense, there is some disconnect between perceptions, as there is, I believe, about the US economy – at least according to media reports and interpretations stoked by the same deference to that lovely conventional word. As noted yesterday, though, not even the stock market is so certain any longer about the potentially positive effects of even more “stimulus.”
The need for it, of that there is no doubt anywhere anymore. Like oil, equities have retired the original “V” narrative because, well, like European consumers it is absolutely clear the global system didn’t achieve nearly as much as it “should” have during the summer months of gigantic positives. |
Stocks w/ WTI Crude, 2020 - Click to enlarge |
| The Fed playing its role in the puppet show, the labor market continues to crack under severe strain. But here again there’s the conditions for misinterpretation.
The big minus continues to be what jobless claims represent – and that’s a labor market still in big trouble when it should have emerged out from trouble weeks if not months ago. However, initial claims continue to fall which can leave the exact opposite impression. These, for example, with California finally catching up its numbers, dropped below 800,000 last week (though not for the first time; revised claims for two weeks before had been less). When you look at the presumed improvement since the beginning of this thing, an astronomical peak of 6.9 million during the week (just the one) of March 28, compared to 6.9 million down to 787,000 it sure seems like an enormously significant if not hugely robust improvement. But it’s not. |
Unemployment Insurance; Initial Jobless Claims, 2017-2020 - Click to enlarge |
| That is making the wrong comparison. To show you what I mean, I’ve removed (above) not just the 11 shutdown weeks from March to May, I’ve further removed the first 12 weeks of the reopening phase (which were awful). That leaves only the last eight weeks (up to and including last week) during which nearly 7 million former American workers filed for benefits payments from their state government.
Remember, the economy is supposed to be doing well on its way back to full recovery by now. Instead, this 6.8 million in jobless claims is, by far, worse than any other eight-week stretch in history before March 2020. It is substantially more labor market destruction than the worst two months of the Great “Recession.” That’s not what anyone had in mind for September and half of October, edging closer and closer to next year at what continues to be an absolutely alarming shortfall. |
Unemployment Insurance; Initial Jobless Claims, 1980-2020 - Click to enlarge |
|
When you take out the prior 33 weeks, the last eight – which, yes, have been the best so far- in historical comparison these are way beyond ugly. Do people really not remember what it was like during the worst two months of 2009 in the US labor market? Of course they do. What’s different is, unbelievably, QE and federal spending. Ben Bernanke during that prior contraction appears today timid and uncertain, President Obama’s widely derided ARRA small and meek, given what Jay Powell and the current federal government are both projecting. Not doing, because QE doesn’t do much, feds spending a stipend not “stimulus”, but both leaving the impression – via a compliant, uncritical media – that this stuff is “ultra-accommodative.” Just don’t ask anyone how it works; and that includes the Fed. |
 . |
| I’ve written this many times before, and it bears repeating once again. Some have likened QE, in particular, to cocaine or speed or whatever sort of drug that drives its user into a manic-type state. That’s instead what those who think QE is money printing, or fed aid as “stimulus”, might be impressed with.
Closer to the truth, QE is anesthesia. It is designed to put you to sleep or at worst numb enough of your senses so that you don’t realize just how bad off you actually are. Only, in a medical setting there’s a doctor there who actually knows how to fix or cure your ailments; at least prevent your death right there on the spot. In monetary policy, Europe’s like America’s (or Japan’s), you’re in the operating room with gaping wounds thinking Jay Powell’s the attending surgeon when instead he’s only the anesthesiologist. |
Unemployment Insurance, Continued Claims, 2017-2020 - Click to enlarge |
| Worse, he has no idea who the real doctor is or when – or if – the actual physician might show up.
But he’s going to give you the drug anyway because, in his view, it’s for your own good. But don’t you dare blame him for what comes next. Patient, heal thyself. |
Department of Labor; Persons Claiming UI Benefits, 2020 - Click to enlarge |
You Might Also Like
Science of Sentiment: Zooming Expectations Wonder
It had been an unusually heated gathering, one marked by temper tantrums and often publicly expressed rancor. Slamming tables, undiplomatic rudeness. Europe’s leaders had been brought together by the uncomfortable even dangerous fact that the economic dislocation they’ve put their countries through is going to sustain enormously negative pressures all throughout them. What would a “united” European system do to try and fill in this massive hole?The marathon bargaining session began on an ominously hot Friday in late July with birthday celebrations and was expected to breezily wrap up by the following Sunday. By the Monday morning, however, the gloves had come off and high-level talks were often replaced by mid-level staff meetings to hammer out details the bosses, apparently, could no
ECB Doubles Its QE; Or, The More Central Banks Do The Worse You Know It Will Be
A perpetual motion machine is impossible, but what about a perpetual inflation machine? This is supposed to be the printing press and central banks are, they like to say, putting it to good and heavy use. But never the inflation by which to confirm it. So round and round we go. The printing press necessary to bring about consumer price acceleration, only the lack of consumer price acceleration dictates the need for more of the printing press.
Wait A Minute, What’s This Inversion?
Back in the middle of 2018, this kind of thing was at least straight forward and intuitive. If there was any confusion, it wasn’t related to the mechanics, rather most people just couldn’t handle the possibility this was real. Jay Powell said inflation, rate hikes, and accelerating growth. Absolutely hawkish across-the-board.And yet, all the way back in the middle of June 2018 the eurodollar curve started to say, hold on a minute.
Wait A Minute, The Dollar And The Fed’s Bank Reserves Are Directly Not Inversely Related
One small silver lining to the current situation, while Jay Powell is busily trying to sell you his inflation fantasy, he’s actually undermining it at the very same time. No mere challenge to his own “money printing” fiction, either, the Fed’s Chairman is actively disproving the entire enterprise. While he says what he says, pay close attention instead to what he’s done.
Fama 2: No Inflation For Old Central Banks
The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that the core CPI in July 2020 jumped by the most (+0.62%) in almost thirty years. After having dropped month-over-month for three months in a row for the first time in its history, it has posted back to back gains the latest of which pushing the index back above its February level.
This Has To Be A Joke, Because If It’s Not…
After thinking about it all day, I’m still not quite sure this isn’t a joke; a high-brow commitment of utterly brilliant performance art, the kind of Four-D masterpiece of hilarious deception that Andy Kaufman would’ve gone nuts over. I mean, it has to be, right?I’m talking, of course, about Jackson Hole and Jay Powell’s reportedly genius masterstroke.
Why Aren’t Bond Yields Flyin’ Upward? Bidin’ Bond Time Trumps Jay
It’s always something. There’s forever some mystery factor standing in the way. On the topic of inflation, for years it was one “transitory” issue after another. The media, on behalf of the central bankers it holds up as a technocratic ideal, would report these at face value. The more obvious explanation, the argument with all the evidence, just couldn’t be true otherwise it’d collapse the technocracy right down to the ground.And so it was also in the bond market. Inflation and their yields very much related, the lack of the former wasn’t ever used to explain the curious absence of the BOND ROUT!!! No, the US Treasury market has been beset by its own set of “transitory” factors, too. As ridiculous as some of the inflation excuses had been, Verizon’s unlimited wireless data plans the
This Thing Is Only Getting Started; Or, *All* The V’s Are Light On The Right
The Federal Reserve’s models really are the most optimistic of the bunch. With the policy meeting conducted today, no surprises as far as policies go, we now know what ferbus has to say about everything that’s happened this year. Skipping the usual March projections, what with the FOMC totally occupied at the time by a complete global monetary meltdown Jay Powell now says “we saw it coming”, the central bank staff released the calculations performed by its DSGE prodigy concurrent with today’s policy meeting.
Tags: Consumer Confidence,currencies,economy,Europe,Featured,Federal Reserve/Monetary Policy,Fiscal spending,fiscal stimulus,inflation,jobless claims,Markets,newsletter,QE,stimulus