by
Keith Weiner
My articles My siteAbout meMy booksMy videos
Follow on:TwitterFacebook

Picture, if you will, a government that deliberately inflicts bad policy on the people. I know this sounds crazy, and could never happen, but please bear with me.

Suppose the government criminalizes hiring someone who produces less than an arbitrary threshold. Or it forces the closure of all businesses deemed to be non “essential”. Or it makes all employers obtain government permission for a long and growing list of things, and then denies permission arbitrarily and capriciously to some, while constantly raising the compliance burden—and hence cost—to the dwindling survivors.

Whatever the high-minded intentions, the end result is that these policies render some people unemployed and unemployable. Change happens at the margin. The marginal worker loses his job. And each bad policy increment raises the margin further.

The Perverse Outcomes of Bad Policy

If this was the full extent of it, then the politicians who imposed these policies would be voted out of office. And their bad policies would be repealed. A direct connection between cause and effect would make it obvious what happened. People could see that the law, though it had high-sounding reasons, actually achieved a perverse outcome.

No doubt workers want a raise. But when the government enacts a minimum wage law, some workers do not get a raise. They get fired. Those fired workers would be leading the angry pitchfork- and torch-wielding crowd calling to vote the bums out of office.

But for one thing.

How Does the Government Get Away With it?

The politicians say it’s terrible that people can’t find work. We should give them welfare. Plus it seems unfair that the cost of living is so high (which is really due to the relentless rise of regulations, which is the rise of mandatory useless ingredients added to all products). They tell us that we need to pay people who don’t work, and people who do work but don’t earn enough to cover the high cost of living. The cost of living is high, because the high-priced goods include many useless ingredients.

Welfare is how the government gets away with bad policies. Welfare is how they get away with impoverishing the people. Bad policies break the legs of the marginal workers. Welfare doles out free crutches.

The Government Consumes Capital

But the doling out of mass quantities of welfare causes another problem. The government cannot pay for it via taxation alone. In the first place, taxes are unpopular. No matter the high virtue-signal of the reasons for the spending, voters only tolerate so much taxation.

Secondly, a higher tax rate does not result in a higher tax take after a certain point. The famous thought experiment of Art Laffer showed that both a 0% tax rate and a 100% tax rate generate no revenue. Maximum tax revenue is achieved somewhere in the middle. There is a limit to how much tax government can take, no matter how high-handed their tax code. Government budgets would seem to be finite.

But for one thing.

Borrowing to Cover the Spread Between Taxing and Spending

People think that it’s terrible that welfare would be restricted by something as low-sounding as tax revenues. Why can’t the government borrow the difference? There. That was easy. There is no longer any particular limit to their high-spending welfare state.

Deficits are how the government gets away with excessive spending. By selling bonds, they get far more from the people, than they ever could by charging taxes. People willingly, and even enthusiastically, buy bonds. But there are two problems.

The Problems with Government Bonds

One, the government may call it “borrowing”, but it has neither the means nor intent to repay. They consume what they borrow. Their borrowing is a fraud. And it will inevitably lead to a crisis.

Two, taxes take people’s income. People know they are poorer for paying their taxes, and so they spend less. But when they buy bonds, they feel that they are saving. And when bond prices go up—as they have been doing since 1981—bondholders feel richer.

While their capital is fed to the vast maw of the welfare state, they feel richer. They spend more, which is called the “wealth effect”.

This is the problem with the monetary system. Not skyrocketing prices. Sinking honesty.

Enjoy this post? Here’s a few other articles you might like:

Where Does Your Profit Come From?

Moving from Gold-Redeemable to Irredeemable Currency

Condo and Currency Collapse

You Might Also Like

SNB Sight Deposits: Inflation is there, CHF must Rise

2021-09-13

Sight Deposits have risen by +0.2 bn CHF, this means that the SNB is intervening and buying Euros and Dollars.

What Trick did Tricky Dicky Pull 50 Years Ago Today?

2021-08-16

Sometimes, bad luck can strike. But other times, a catastrophe comes from a series of bad decisions, each the reaction to the consequences of the previous one.
On August 15, 1971, President Nixon decreed that the US dollar would no longer be redeemable for the gold owed, even to foreign governments.

Gold Price Smashdown vs Gold on Fire

2021-08-11

No sooner did we write Silver Rorschach Test, than the price of gold flash-crashed, or was smashed down. On Sunday afternoon in Arizona—i.e. Monday morning in Australia and Asia—the gold price dropped sharply. Gold bug sources claim that the drop was $100, but as we can see from the price graph included in this report, the actual crash itself was about $70.

Motivated Reasoning About Silver

2021-07-27

We’re seeing the argument, again, that silver stocks are being consumed in solar panels, medical applications, and of course, electronics. This argument has a certain temptation. After all, the standard assumption is that value is inversely proportional to quantity. Purchasing power is widely believed to be 1 / N (N is number of units of currency issued).

Basel III’s Effect on Gold and Silver

2021-07-13

There is sometimes a tendency to confuse ends and means. For example, in traveling through an airport there is extensive inspection of passengers. Before you are allowed to board an airplane, you must go through a process that is intrusive and increasingly invasive.

Inflation or Lockdown Whiplash?

2021-06-29

Mainstream analysis sees rising consumer prices, and looks for a monetary cause. Also, when it sees an increase in the quantity of dollars, it looks for rising consumer prices. It is a fact that the quantity of what the mainstream calls money (i.e. the dollar) has risen at an extraordinary rate.

What the Heck Just Happened to the Price of Gold and Silver?!

2021-06-22

The price of gold (and silver) was on a tear in April and May. Then some sideways action. And then this week, thud. On Twitter, a popular meme is that the banks smashed the price by selling futures contracts, though there was no selling of gold bars. Let’s just say that if the price of an August contract fell by $120, while the price of a gold bar held steady, there would be a backwardation of around 40%!

Resetting the Federal Debt

2021-06-08

According to the US Treasury, the federal government owes $28.2 trillion. It crossed the “28” threshold on the last day of March. The debt was just under $25 trillion at the end of April a year ago. There’s no question it’s growing at a faster and faster pace, and now there’s the excuse of Covid to spend more.