Saturday , July 11 2020
Home / Personal Investment / DEGIRO vs eToro: Which Is Best For You in 2020?

DEGIRO vs eToro: Which Is Best For You in 2020?

Summary:
(Disclosure: Some of the links below may be affiliate links) There are many good brokers available. So how do you choose between them? Today, we are comparing DEGIRO vs eToro, two brokers that are popular in Europe.If you want to trade in the stock market, you will need a broker account. And you must choose your brokerage company well. You will likely keep the same one for a long time. And changing brokers is a significant pain.DEGIRO is a broker from the Netherlands that advertise very low fees. And eToro is a broker from Israel that mainly advertise social trading.So, how can you choose between the two? This article will help you decide by comparing in detail DEGIRO vs eToro. The comparison will be made on many levels: fees, availability, security, and so on.What is DEGIRO? Best Broker

Topics:
Mr. The Poor Swiss considers the following as important: ,

This could be interesting, too:

Mr. The Poor Swiss writes Should you contribute to your third pillar in 2020?

Mr. The Poor Swiss writes Value Investing: What is it? And should you do it?

Mr. The Poor Swiss writes What is impact investing? And what about ESG investing and SRI?

Mr. The Poor Swiss writes Investing Fees could cost you your early retirement!

(Disclosure: Some of the links below may be affiliate links)

DEGIRO vs eToro: Which Is Best For You in 2020?

There are many good brokers available. So how do you choose between them? Today, we are comparing DEGIRO vs eToro, two brokers that are popular in Europe.

If you want to trade in the stock market, you will need a broker account. And you must choose your brokerage company well. You will likely keep the same one for a long time. And changing brokers is a significant pain.

DEGIRO is a broker from the Netherlands that advertise very low fees. And eToro is a broker from Israel that mainly advertise social trading.

So, how can you choose between the two? This article will help you decide by comparing in detail DEGIRO vs eToro. The comparison will be made on many levels: fees, availability, security, and so on.

What is DEGIRO?

Best Broker for Europe
DEGIRO

DEGIRO is a great broker for Europe, with extremely affordable fees! Trade securities for as little as 0.5 CHF!

Let’s start with DEGIRO.

DEGIRO is a brokerage company from The Netherlands. It was founded in 2018. They are offering their services in 18 countries. They have been available in Switzerland since 2018. They are claiming about half a million dollars.

The main selling point of DEGIRO is its low fees. Their fees is what they are using to advertise their companies. They have been growing very fast because of this. They are employing more than 200 people.

They are offering access to many investing instruments (stocks, bonds ETFs, CFDs, and so on) in many different stock exchanges.

If you want more information about them, I have written a full review of DEGIRO.

Keep in mind that DEGIRO currently has a waiting list for opening an account, due to the coronavirus crisis.

What is eToro?

eToro is a brokerage company founded in 2007 in Israel. They are now operating in more than 140 countries and claim 11 million users. The company is currently valued at over 800 million dollars. These are impressive numbers!

eToro selling points are on two fronts:

  • Their low commissions.
  • Their social trading systems.

The first point is self-explanatory. But the second point is where eToro differ from other brokerage companies. They have two significant features for that. They have the CopyTrading feature that you can use to copy the trades made by the most successful traders in the customers. And you can also use the CopyPortfolio feature to copy the portfolios of other users or famous investors.

They offer access to many investing instruments: stocks, bonds, ETFs, CFDs, and even cryptocurrencies.

Which has better minimums?

Let’s trade to compare the minimum of DEGIRO vs eToro.

First, eToro has a minimum deposit limit of 200$. It means you will need at least this amount to start trading with them. On the other hand, DEGIRO has no minimum deposits. So you can start with a tiny amount. It is probably not a big deal since this a tiny minimum.

Something that I find peculiar is the minimum trade size at eToro. Since 2017, you cannot trade stocks or ETFs with less than 500$. For me, this is just plain stupid. If I want one share of a stock that is worth 60$, I should be able to do so. DEGIRO does not have any minimum trade size.

So, DEGIRO has much better minimums than eToro since it does not have any minimum!

Which is more available? DEGIRO vs Toro?

First of all, let’s check the availability of DEGIRO vs eToro in the world.

eToro is available in more than 60 countries, including the United States. There are some countries where eToro is blocked.

On the other hand, DEGIRO is available in 18 European countries.

From an availability point of view, eToro is much better than DEGIRO.

Which has better support in Switzerland?

We cannot look at the detail of each country. But let’s look at the detail for these two brokers in Switzerland.

As a Swiss, you can open an account with both platforms. However, there is an essential difference regarding currency.

DEGIRO offers access to Swiss Francs (CHF) if you have a Swiss account. It means you can deposit money directly (and for free) to your account in CHF.

On the other hand, eToro operates with U.S. Dollar (USD). You can deposit dollars directly to your account. They are also supporting deposits in a few other currencies (EUR, GBP, AUD, RMB, THB, IDR, MYR, VND, PHP).

It means you cannot deposit CHF to your account. So, you will have to convert it otherwise, for instance, with Revolut or TransferWise. Or with your bank, but this will be excruciatingly expensive.

If you are paid in EUR, you will be able to deposit your money on eToro. However, this will not be free. And this is extremely expensive. You will pay a 2.5% fee on each deposit and withdrawal. This fee is terrible.

Regarding access to stocks, DEGIRO and eToro give you access to the SIX Stock exchange. SIX is the principal stock exchange in Switzerland. It means that both brokers will provide you with access to all the Swiss shares you need.

So, for Swiss investors, DEGIRO is miles better than eToro. eToro is only acceptable if you have USD directly. Otherwise, the conversion fees are terrible.

Which has more features? DEGIRO vs eToro

We can take a look at the features that both brokers offer.

They both offer a mobile application and a web application. From what I have seen, eToro applications are better designed and more polished than DEGIRO applications. But this is mostly a matter of taste. And they are both aimed at being very simple to use even for beginners.

For trading, both brokers are offering similar features. You can buy and sell shares with the typical stock market order types. There is nothing special here for neither of the two brokers. They both have more trading features than you need.

One difference is that DEGIRO does not let you trade currencies. You can only hold one currency in your account. Once you buy something in another currency, it will be automatically converted (for a fee). eToro, on the other hand, lets you trade currencies directly.

From a research point of view, eToro offers more information on each stock than DEGIRO does.  For me, this does not matter since I only invest in very few ETFs. But for some people doing more active trading, this could be important.

On top of that, DEGIRO does not have other features.

On the other hand, eToro has several features for what they call social trading. As I mentioned in the introduction, with eToro, you can copy the trades of another investor, or you can replicate some famous portfolios. Again, I do not think this matters much if you are a simple passive investor. But these features are still quite interesting.

eToro makes it very easy to use advanced features. It may be why 75% of people on eToro are losing money. Leverage investing should not be easy to use. On the other hand, even with DEGIRO, the majority of users are losing money.

So, eToro has many more features than DEGIRO. But it only matters if you need these features.

DEGIRO vs eToro – Which is cheaper?

Both brokers are cheap, so let’s see which of DEGIRO vs eToro is cheaper.

For stocks and ETFs (the only two things I am interested in), eToro has zero-fees! Yes, you heard that right, you can trade in stocks and ETFs for free with eToro. This commission-free trading is only for long positions without leverage. But this is fine because we are all about passive investing here.

On the other hand, DEGIRO is only free for a few ETFs on a chosen list. DEGIRO has low fees on most exchanges.

We can compare both to take a look at the difference:

OperationeToroDEGIRO
Buy 10000 USD of Apple0 USD0.63 EUR
Buy 5000 CHF of Novartis0 USD7.50 CHF
Buy 1000 EUR of Audi0 USD4.50 EUR

So, at first sight, eToro is much cheaper than DEGIRO. While DEGIRO is still cheap compared to other brokers, eToro zero-commission trading cannot be beaten.

Now, that is true only if you can transfer USD directly to your eToro. As we have seen before, eToro does not accept CHF. It means you will have to convert it somehow. And while it does accept EUR, it charges a horrendous fee of 2.5% per deposit and per withdrawal. This insane fee completely dwarves all the fees you would ever pay with DEGIRO.

We can shortly talk about Forex trading as well. DEGIRO does not allow you to trade currencies. Once you need another currency, it will be converted automatically. This conversion will cost 0.10% of the transaction. This fee is not negligible.

On the other hand, eToro lets you buy foreign currency. The fees are varying from the currency pair, from 0.03% to 0.50%. You can find the actual spreads here.

Finally, let’s look at non-trading fees. Deposits are free with both brokers. Withdrawals are free with DEGIRO but will cost 5 USD for eToro. Also, eToro has an inactivity fee of 10 USD per month if you have not logged in to your account in a year. I think everybody can pretty much ignore this fee since everybody should connect at least once a year to their broker account.

DEGIRO has one extra fee: the exchange connectivity fee. For each exchange you use (excluding your local stock exchange), you will pay 2.50 EUR per year.

Which is more secure?

Let’s take a look at the security of DEGIRO vs eToro. Your assets must be secure if you plan to invest a large amount of money.

Both brokers are well regulated with European and International laws. Since eToro operates in many countries, they have to comply with several different laws. So, based on where your account will be, there will be different regulations. The Netherlands Authorities regulate DEGIRO.

In both cases, you will have the same protection of 20’000 EUR if you are using their European accounts. This protection is only protecting your cash. Assets should generally be in your name and, as such, be safe from bankruptcy.

DEGIRO and eToro are holding your assets in segregated accounts. Segregation means that your assets are not in their balance sheets but a subsidiary company. This segregation is essential because this should ensure that if the main company bankrupts, your assets are safe with the second company.

In both cases, when you buy stocks, you will directly buy the real stocks, and they will be held in your name. Now, there are two exceptions to consider.

First, by default, DEGIRO will be able to lend your assets. It means that they can decide to lend your assets to a short seller without you knowing. It incurs a small extra risk. You can negate that risk by opting for a DEGIRO Custody account, but you will pay some fees on dividends.

eToro also has some exceptions where stocks are held as Contracts for Differences (CFDs) and not real stocks directly. For European investors, this should not be a problem unless you use the Milan Stock Exchange or the Helsinki, Copenhagen, and Oslo stock exchanges. In these stock exchanges, stocks are purchased with CFDs. You should read the list of eToro exceptions to be sure.

CFDs are not regulated as well as stocks and not protected as well either. So, if something happens to eToro, you will not have the same level of protection as if you had stocks.

From a technical point of view, both brokers are secure. They both offer Two-Factor Authentication. And I have not found any information about leaks or breaches in any of the brokers.

When comparing DEGIRO vs eToro, both offer the same level of security. They are well regulated and technically secure. You just need to be careful about the small letters such as stock lending and possible CFDs.

If you want more information on security, read how to secure your online personal finances.

Reputation -DEGIRO vs eToro

We can also compare the reputation of DEGIRO vs eToro.

Both brokers have an average reputation. They both have some big fans and some big detractors. But they do not have a great reputation.

Let’s take a look at the user reviews of DEGIRO on TrustPilot. They are graded at 3.1 out of 5. The main issues pointed out by customers are mainly about customer service (or the lack of customer service). Other problems are related to withdrawals that seem to be slow in some countries.

We also need to keep in mind that many reports are simply people that did not read the conditions and are salty for paying a fee they did not research. Let’s also keep in mind that many people are complaining about the waiting list that is in place during the coronavirus crisis.

Let’s do the same for the user reviews of eToro on TrustPilot. They manage to do worse than DEGIRO, with 2.4 out of 5. The main complaint about eToro is that they change the fees and the conditions too often. It means that when you create your account, the conditions could be different than a few months later when you trade.

Other complaints are about the very high currency conversion fees and the high spreads. Many people also complain about the lack of transparency in the way zero-commission is advertised. They also seem to have several issues in the execution of orders, which is concerning. Finally, there are also some complaints about customer service, but fewer than for DEGIRO.

Some of the bad eToro reviews are simply people that did not do research. But the official information indeed lacks transparency for fees.

When comparing the reputation of DEGIRO vs eToro, DEGIRO has better reviews than eToro. But neither of them has a great reputation.

DEGIRO vs eToro – Summary

To finish this comparison, here is a summary of the primary comparison points between the two services:

CriteriaeToroDEGIRO
Trading featuresGoodGood
Extra featuresSocial TradingNone
Trading feesZeroLow
Deposit conversionExtremely expensiveFree
ForexOkayNone
TransparencyBadOkay
Customer ServiceAveragePoor
ReputationPoorAverage
SecurityAverageAverage

There is some good and some bad with each of these two brokers. eToro has extra features for social trading and offers zero-commission fees. However, eToro is bad if you do not have USD to deposit on their accounts. Because of that, it will be more expensive than DEGIRO.

You need to be careful about that because a lot of people do not realize that before they start depositing money on their account. I would never use eToro unless I could directly deposit USD into my account.

Also, eToro lacks in transparency and makes a lot of changes to their policies and fees without the proper information. Some of the things I have read about this make me wary about them. But I will let you form your own opinion.

DEGIRO vs eToro Conclusion

Best Broker for Europe
DEGIRO

DEGIRO is a great broker for Europe, with extremely affordable fees! Trade securities for as little as 0.5 CHF!

We have now compared DEGIRO vs eToro in detail.

DEGIRO and eToro are very different brokerages. DEGIRO is suited to European countries, while eToro is more of an international brokerage.

Now, for Swiss investors, DEGIRO is much better than eToro. Since eToro does not support CHF deposits, you will have to convert your money yourself either with your bank or with a service such as Revolut. But this is highly inconvenient. And even if you have access to EUR, the conversion fees are just outrageous (2.5%!).

I think that eToro is only good if you have access to USD. Otherwise, it simply does not make sense. The fees you are going to pay for the conversions will outweigh the benefits of having zero-commissions trading, and by far!

On the other hand, DEGIRO handles CHF and EUR deposits and also has very low fees.

If you want to learn about another alternative to DEGIRO, read my comparison of DEGIRO and Interactive Brokers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *