by The following article was written by Keith Weiner, CEO of Monetary Metals, as a counterpoint to this article, POINT: Should the US Return to the Gold Standard? No It was originally published at InsideSources, here: COUNTERPOINT: Is the Gold Standard the Economists’ Punching Bag? In many gyms, there is a punching bag in the corner. When someone feels frustrated or wants to show off, he can hit it. The gold standard is the punching bag in the economists’ gym. In an InsideSources op-ed, David Beckworth and Patrick Horan argue, “A new gold standard would do much more harm than good.” They posit that we should not return to the currency price-fixing scheme of 1944-1971. They are convincing, but unfortunately, they knocked down a straw man. The authors concede that the
Topics:
Keith Weiner considers the following as important: 6a) Gold & Monetary Metals, 6a.) Monetary Metals, blog, Featured, Monetary Metals In the News, newsletter
This could be interesting, too:
Eamonn Sheridan writes CHF traders note – Two Swiss National Bank speakers due Thursday, November 21
Charles Hugh Smith writes How Do We Fix the Collapse of Quality?
Marc Chandler writes Sterling and Gilts Pressed Lower by Firmer CPI
Michael Lebowitz writes Trump Tariffs Are Inflationary Claim The Experts
The following article was written by Keith Weiner, CEO of Monetary Metals, as a counterpoint to this article, POINT: Should the US Return to the Gold Standard? No
It was originally published at InsideSources, here: COUNTERPOINT: Is the Gold Standard the Economists’ Punching Bag?
In many gyms, there is a punching bag in the corner. When someone feels frustrated or wants to show off, he can hit it. The gold standard is the punching bag in the economists’ gym.
In an InsideSources op-ed, David Beckworth and Patrick Horan argue, “A new gold standard would do much more harm than good.” They posit that we should not return to the currency price-fixing scheme of 1944-1971. They are convincing, but unfortunately, they knocked down a straw man.
The authors concede that the pre-1913 gold coin standard worked well. And then dismiss it, because people want a vast welfare state, and central banks want to keep their power. Do they? Maybe, but it should not be dismissed so lightly.
Beckworth and Horan propose that the central bank should push the levers and turn the knobs of monetary policy to engineer the right amount of growth. Who determines the right amount of growth, not to mention the right means of achieving it?
Consider the Soviet experiment in central planning of wheat. Sounds simple: plant seeds, wait for sun and rain, then harvest and distribute. This experiment horribly failed and caused millions to starve to death.
No one argues anymore for central planning of crops. Instead, they advocate central planning of credit. Credit is anything but simple, and the effects can lag policy changes for years. If central planning of wheat is impossible, it is a billion times more impossible to centrally plan the growth of an economy by mucking with money and credit.
It is also unjust. Beckworth and Horan blithely say that inflation “reduces the severity of debt burdens and stimulates the (economy).” Inflation steals the savings of workers and retirees.
The savings of the people are up for grabs because they are forced to save in irredeemable currency. They are forced to lend to a banking system. To hold a paper dollar bill is to grant a dollar of credit to the Federal Reserve, which lends it to the government and banks.
The Fed grabs their savings bit by bit, because people want welfare, the central bankers want power, borrowers want to pay debts back in cheaper dollars, and the economy wants to be stimulated.
A proper gold standard is simply when people have a choice. When they are not forced, they choose gold as they have done for thousands of years.
Another choice is whether to hold gold coins or deposit them in a bank. This is important because people deposit gold if they like the interest rate (and the risk). Their refusal to deposit when the rate is too low is like grocery store customers refusing to buy steak when the price is too high. The bank and grocer have to offer a better price if they want business.
People are forced away from gold by legal tender laws, the tax code, and many laws and regulations. We do not need to pass more laws and the Fed does not need to impose a new policy, to nudge people to gold. The government needs to get out of the way and repeal particular capital gains taxes on gold (which is just inflation).
Why not let people choose for themselves? If an irredeemable currency inflated by a central bank is really superior, then wouldn’t it knock out gold in a fair competition?
Additional Resources to Understand the Gold Standard
The Unadulterated Gold Standard (five-part series)
What’s the Real Purpose of Money?
PODCAST: Why the Dollar isn’t Money
VIDEO: What will the Coming Gold Standard Look Like?
VIDEO: Why am I Fighting for the Gold Standard?
You Might Also Like
SNB Sight Deposits: Inflation is there, CHF must Rise
2021-08-16
Sight Deposits have risen by +2.7 bn CHF, this means that the SNB is intervening and buying Euros and Dollars.
What Trick did Tricky Dicky Pull 50 Years Ago Today?
2021-08-16
Sometimes, bad luck can strike. But other times, a catastrophe comes from a series of bad decisions, each the reaction to the consequences of the previous one.
On August 15, 1971, President Nixon decreed that the US dollar would no longer be redeemable for the gold owed, even to foreign governments.
Celebrating Five Years of Interest on Gold
2021-07-23
This month marks the five-year anniversary of Monetary Metals paying interest on gold. It was July 2016 when we offered our first Gold Fixed Income True Gold Lease. The gold lease was to Valaurum for manufacturing their flagship product, the Aurum®. It paid 3.0% interest on gold to investors (you can read the original press release here).
The Truth about the Silver Squeeze
2021-04-27
Some recent videos about the silver market are generating more buzz than we have seen in a while. They make several points, but the main one is that there is a global shortage of silver. This assertion stands in contradiction to the fact that the silver price has dropped. As of the date of the first of these videos, it had dropped around 10% from its level just a month earlier.
Episode 19 – Bonus Episode! Theory of Interest and Prices Mises Conference 2021
2021-04-17
Keith presented his Theory of Interest and Prices at the Mises’ Austrian Economics Research Conference earlier this year. Described as one of the most interesting talks of the entire event, this episode includes his fifteen-minute presentation as well as some follow-up thoughts by Keith himself at the end.
Monetary Metals Issues Gold Token
2021-04-01
Scottsdale, Ariz, April 1, 2021— Monetary Metals® announces that it has issued a gold token. Unlike the company’s other products, this one is not designed to pay a yield.
In a sign of the times, the company intends this product to generate big speculative gains. It is designed to GO UP!
Episode 17: Why Fedcoin?
2021-03-30
Our recent article on Fedcoin – a digital currency being considered by the Federal Reserve – revealed the sinister and pernicious reasons behind such a move. This week’s episode of The Gold Exchange Podcast explores the topic further. In it, John Flaherty and CEO Keith Weiner discuss: Addl description of episode
The Fedcoin is Coming, 8 March
2021-03-09
Before we talk about Fedcoins, let’s look at the old school non-digital, non-blockchain, coin. Gold. And silver. Since January 4, the price has dropped about $244. And the price of silver has fallen about $4. Are these buying opportunities? Or the end of the brief gold bull market of 2020 (i.e. Covid)?
Tags: Blog,Featured,Monetary Metals In the News,newsletter