by
Thorsten Polleit
My articles My siteAbout meMy booksMy videos
Follow on:TwitterLinkedIN

The Berlin “housing crisis” has, of course, many causes. But most, if not all of them, are government made. Unfortunately, however, people blame “capitalists” for their plight.

Original Article: “Berliners in 2021 Want to Expropriate Private Housing”

On September 6, 2021, the city-state of Berlin, Germany’s capital, held a referendum: voters in Berlin had to decide whether thousands of housing units owned by “large real estate firms” should be nationalized. 56.4 percent voted yes, 39 percent no. While the referendum is not binding, it forces Berlin’s incoming city government to debate the expropriation measure. However, whichever way you look at it, it certainly is an expropriation attempt: the term “expropriation” is even openly stated in the name of the grassroots campaign, “Expropriation Deutsche Wohnen and Co,” and it suggests a compensation of the properties “well below market value.”

Housing is scarce in Berlin, and rents continue to rise. This already led the city government to declare a freeze on rent prices (“Mietpreisbremse”) as early as June 2015, which, however, was turned down by the German Supreme Court in April of this year. During the rent freeze, what happened was what sound economics would predict: new construction declined, and investors started building single-family homes rather than apartments—as the latter were not subject to the rent price freeze. The measure has significantly worsened the housing situation in Berlin.

The Berlin “housing crisis” has, of course, many causes. But most, if not all of them, are government made. In particular, the European Central Bank’s ultralow interest rate and money expansion policy is causing real estate prices to skyrocket. Building a home or renting a decent apartment becomes less and less affordable for many people. Unfortunately, however, people blame “capitalists” for their plight. They do not understand—or do not want to see—that the state and the state-sponsored central bank are at the heart of the troubles.

The shocking element of the Berlin referendum is that private property is openly attacked and that, no less shocking, there is little public outcry against such a coup. Well, you may say, it is only Berlin, a notoriously leftist city, economically pretty much entirely dependent on government handouts (which were previously wrested from the hands of net tax producers), not representative of the rest of Germany. Indeed, Berlin is special. But the Berlin referendum nevertheless shows that in today’s world, private property isn’t sacrosanct; it is under attack.

Private property is the linchpin of a free society, of peaceful and productive cooperation between people. Socialists of all stripes want to relativize, undermine, and even destroy private property altogether. This is why private property must be defended. Ludwig von Mises (1881–1973) was well aware of this when he wrote in 1922: “Natural ownership need not count upon recognition by the owners’ fellow men. It is, in fact, only tolerated as long as there is no power to upset it, and it does not survive the moment when a stronger man seizes it for himself.”

Questioning lawfully acquired private property is not only immoral but also economically self-destructive. Berliners have certainly set a rather bad example, which hopefully will not turn out to be a precedent. Hopefully, every owner of private property will finally take a stand against the ongoing encroachments by the government, which has made great efforts to foster an anticapitalist mentality among the populace over the past decades. One thing is clear: without confidence in the institution of private property, prosperity and peace would be doomed to failure.

This Audio Mises Wire is generously sponsored by Christopher Condon. Narrated by Michael Stack.

You Might Also Like

The Economic Foundations of Freedom

2021-10-07

Animals are driven by instinctive urges. They yield to the impulse that prevails at the moment and peremptorily asks for satisfaction. They are the puppets of their appetites. Man’s eminence is to be seen in the fact that he chooses between alternatives. He regulates his behavior deliberatively.

Currency Debasement and Social Collapse

2021-10-03

Knowledge of the effects of government interference with market prices makes us comprehend the economic causes of a momentous historical event, the decline of ancient civilization.

Too Much Inflation? Just Raise the Inflation Target!

2021-09-26

In late August, Fed chairman Jerome Powell suggested that the Federal Reserve would begin tapering before the end of the year, an admission that price inflation was rising above the 2 percent target. Nonetheless, the Fed took no immediate action in the following month.

Can Economic Data Explain the Timing and Causes of Recessions?

2021-09-20

Most economists are of the view that through the inspection of economic data it is possible to identify early warning signs regarding boom bust cycles. What is the rationale behind this way of thinking?

War Has Declined in the West Because War Isn’t “Worth It” for Rich Countries

2021-09-17

The triumph of peace in contemporary societies is expressed as an obvious fact by mainstream intellectuals. Noting the relatively peaceful state of the world is part of a broader narrative to paint a positive picture of humanity. Yet there is a kernel truth to the assertion that quality of life indicators are improving, as explored by Marian Tupy and other optimists. But the game of warfare is more complicated.

The Fed: Why Federal Spending Soared in 2020 but State and Local Spending Flatlined

2021-06-28

In the wake of the Covid Recession and the drive to pour ever larger amounts of “stimulus” into the US economy, the Federal Government in 2020 spent more than double—as a percentage of all government spending—of what all state and local governments spent in 2020, combined.

Why Monetary “Stimulus” Won’t Prevent an Economic Bust

2021-06-10

The increase in the growth rate of the Consumer Price Index (CPI) has fueled concerns that if the rising trend were to continue the Fed is likely to tighten its interest rate stance. Observe that the yearly growth rate in the CPI climbed to 4.2 percent in April from 2.6 percent in March and 0.3 percent in April 2020.

More Evidence the American Economic “Recovery” Will Disappoint

2021-05-28

The University of Michigan consumer confidence index fell to 82.8 in May, from 88.3 in April. More importantly, the current conditions index slumped to 90.8, from 97.2 and the expectations index declined to 77.6, from 82.7. Hard data also questions the strength of the recovery.