Ukraine: What Swiss sanctions-busters need to consider

by
Swissinfo
My articles My booksMy videos
Follow on:TwitterFacebookGoogle +

Legal expert Mark Pieth is amazed that Switzerland is taking its own problematic approach to international sanctions against Russia.

Opinion by Mark Pieth

When Russia invaded Ukraine, the US and the EU announced economic sanctions, whereas Switzerland announced that it would first have to analyse the new situation. The obvious question there is what has the Swiss Government been doing for the past few weeks, as tensions have been rising?

The real problem, however, is that Switzerland announced it would take some measures to reduce the risk of circumvention of sanctions, but it didn’t envisage blocking funds of anyone close to the Russian regime. Simply no new money would be allowed to be deposited in Switzerland.

This approach may be understandable from a purely economic point of view. After all, Switzerland is the seat of [gas pipelines] Nord Stream 1 and 2, and isn’t a large part of Russian oil traded through Geneva, including by Russian oligarchs? Yet the official Swiss attitude echoes the experiences that the world had with Switzerland during the Second World War, the Cold War and Apartheid: neutrality was considered a licence to do business with anyone, including criminal regimes.

The Swiss-based business community needs to be aware that for them the official Swiss stance could become rapidly irrelevant. Imagine a bank continuing to lend its services to companies and individuals on the US or EU sanctions list, a not-totally-unlikely scenario. This would not go down well with the rest of the Western world.

It may be that the bank itself is put on the sanctions list as an accomplice of the sanctioned entity. There are ways to declare the bank a “primary money-laundering concern”. As an ultimate means, does the international community still need this bank as a correspondent bank? The price of becoming a pariah could be really high, whatever official Switzerland says.

And maybe robust action against Swiss-based sanctions-busters by foreign powers is needed. There are times when being inadequate simply has no place. Let’s remember what Stuart Eizenstat, former US Under Secretary of Commerce for International Trade, said when discussing the role of Switzerland during the Second World War: “Neutrality collided with morality; too often, being neutral provided a pretext for avoiding moral considerations”.

The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the views of SWI swissinfo.ch.

In compliance with the JTI standards

More: SWI swissinfo.ch certified by the Journalism Trust Initiative

You Might Also Like

After pandemic slump, Swiss exports boomed in 2021

2022-01-28

Swiss exports climbed to record levels in 2021, with chemicals and pharma driving much of the growth. Watches, especially luxury ones, also had a good year.

Swiss cantons mull lower taxes for wealthy executives

2022-01-17

Swiss Finance Minister Ueli Maurer has hinted that cantons might lower income taxes for well-heeled executives as the country braces for the impact of a minimum corporate tax rate.

Swiss central bank forecasts CHF26bn annual profit

2022-01-11

The Swiss National Bank (SNB) expects to post a profit of CHF26 billion ($28 billion) for 2021, a windfall made exclusively from its growing foreign currency holdings.

Why Switzerland props up its ailing sugar industry

2021-12-11

Every year from October to December more than 1.5 million tonnes of sugar beets grown in Switzerland are harvested to supply the country’s sugar industry – an industry being kept alive by massive government subsidies. SWI swissinfo.ch reports from Aarberg, home to the country’s largest sugar factory.  

Call to tap potential of professional working women

2021-11-17

Women make up half of the highly skilled workforce in Switzerland, but work fewer hours, according to a study published on Tuesday. One in three would like to work more, under certain conditions.

Geneva-Lausanne train link remains suspended

2021-11-12

The holes were caused by tunneling work under the tracks carried out by a private company, which was working on a thermal energy project using water from Lake Geneva to heat an industrial zone not far from the train line. Keystone / Jean-christophe Bott

The main rail link between Geneva and Lausanne in southwestern Switzerland will not re-open until Friday morning, Swiss Federal Railways (SBB/CFF) has confirmed. The line has been suspended since Tuesday after land collapsed near the tracks.
This content was published on November 11, 2021 – 09:57
November 11, 2021 – 09:57

Keystone-SDA/sb

Holes that appeared between tracks at Tolochenaz, near Morges in canton Vaud, on Tuesday still require major work, which is proving more complicated than expected, the Federal Railways said.Two holes

Swiss expats thrown limited banking lifeline by digital disruptor

2021-11-10

Digital bank Yapeal is offering basic accounts to Swiss people living in neighbouring countries that undercut the rising fees of mainstream competitors. 

‘Fantasy Basel’ re-opens after a two-year Covid break

2021-10-11

The three-day Fantasy Basel festival for fans of films, games, comics, cosplay and manga has re-opened its doors after a two-year break.